Blog |

Can a large city end homelessness?

Large cities face unique challenges, but have successfully driven reductions in homelessness.
  |  March 29, 2021

Homelessness is solvable. In Built for Zero, 14 communities have proven it, reaching a dynamic milestone for ending homelessness for a population, known as functional zero. So far, 51 communities have achieved a measurable reduction. 

When we share this information, it usually prompts a question: but what about large cities? 

It’s understandable. To date, the communities that have reached functional zero are small to mid-sized communities. But the exciting news is that large cities are not far behind.

We work with a host of large cities, including six of the 20 largest cities in the country. And five large cities participating in the movement have driven reductions of 20% or more in chronic or veteran homelessness.  

What every community needs to end homelessness

The good news, is that our experience has demonstrated that the critical features of an operating system designed to end homelessness are the same, regardless of the size of the community:

shared aim

A shared aim

Every community needs a shared aim of measurably and equitably ending homelessness — defining success not in individually held programmatic goals, but by whether the number of people experiencing homelessness is going down. 

single team

A single, nimble team

All the key actors that serve the population need to be working together, combining their efforts and resources. This team needs to be able to nimbly respond to the changing nature of homelessness in their geography.

Comprehensive real-time, by-name data

All of the efforts in a community need to be guided by a real-time understanding of homelessness, which includes every person experiencing homelessness by name. This individual- and population-level data is used to target resources, test new ideas, and understand whether efforts are driving reductions. 

Challenges for large cities working to solve homelessness

But there are also unique challenges. Three in particular:

1. Complex governance structures.

Homeless response in large metro areas is often subject to cumbersome, hybrid governance structures (e.g. city/county joint powers authorities) that diffuse power and make nimble decision-making difficult. These structures usually start out as a compromise designed to help city and county political leaders work together across a large area. But because they split up the decision-making authority between frequently opposing political factions, the result is more often paralysis.

2. Tight housing markets

Large cities often have higher cost housing markets where federally backed rental vouchers are less competitive. This requires targeted real estate investments to produce more dedicated housing stock.

3. Larger populations experiencing homelessness

Larger, more densely populated cities usually start out with much bigger populations of people experiencing homelessness. It’s natural that it takes them longer to drive to zero. The key thing to look for early on in these communities is whether homelessness is trending in the right direction (downward) over time.

“… Jacksonville is leading the way on ending veteran homelessness.”

— Dawn Gilman, Chief Executive Officer of Changing Homelessness

Proof of possibility in large cities

These challenges are big but not insurmountable. Communities have required more time to design and operationalize systems that can drive toward zero — and to secure the resources to close the housing gaps that often emerge— but they can and do make progress!

Even in the midst of the pandemic, cities like Detroit and Jacksonville, Florida, have driven dramatic reductions in veteran homelessness, for example. 

Detroit reduced veteran homelessness by 33% in 2020. A big component of their success? Collaboration.

“Systems work best when they’re not working in silos. And I always say — we’re just smarter together,” said Tom Albanese, a VA Technical Assistance provider working with Detroit.

Dawn Gilman, Chief Executive Officer of Changing Homelessness, is a leader working to end veteran homelessness in Duval County, Florida. This includes Jacksonville, the largest city by area in the continental U.S,

“Homelessness in large cities can appear daunting, confusing, and even overwhelming,” she said. “By focusing on the goal of ending homelessness, looking at real time data to determine where people were and what they needed, and a community wide willingness to work together in new ways, Jacksonville is leading the way on ending veteran homelessness.”

Jake Maguire is a Principal at Community Solutions, where he co-directs the Built for Zero team, which executes the organization’s systems change work to help communities end homelessness throughout the U.S. and around the world.